Parenting the Supernanny way does not improve behaviour
5 posters
Breast Buddies Natural Parenting And Breastfeeding Support Forum. Attachment Parenting :: Pregnancy ,Breastfeeding and Parenting Related News :: Pregnancy, Breastfeeding and Parenting Related News
Page 1 of 1
Kasia80- Number of posts : 4575
Age : 44
From : Oxfordshire
Tell us about yourself : \"If breastfeeding in public makes people uneasy because the breasts are considered sexual, then bottle-feeding must be the equivalent of whipping out a dildo\"
Your mood today : Happy
Thanks and Reputation points : 20
Points : 549
Registration date : 2007-08-04
Re: Parenting the Supernanny way does not improve behaviour
I disagree with the article. What's the British Medical Journal got anything to do with it? I don't believe in smacking either and 'time out' does work. Why have they infered that 'yelling' could be better? Parents need to be consistant, I doubt a small research project would reflect the true answers here. Children thrive on bounderies, they are needed, and from nurturing, loving parents.
clinically significant conduct disorders. WTF?! Pee off British Medical Journal and leave it to the parents!
clinically significant conduct disorders. WTF?! Pee off British Medical Journal and leave it to the parents!
Re: Parenting the Supernanny way does not improve behaviour
I read the article as the whole point IS to leave it to the parents - one method doesnt work over another.
I think at the end of the day, whatever discipline method is used, how the child turns out is down to the parent, and like you said, boundaries need to be in place. Its how the parent manages those boundaries that determines the end result.
I think at the end of the day, whatever discipline method is used, how the child turns out is down to the parent, and like you said, boundaries need to be in place. Its how the parent manages those boundaries that determines the end result.
kay- Breast Buddies
- Number of posts : 5435
Age : 44
From : North Wales
Tell us about yourself : Mummy to 4 beautiful boys!
Your mood today : Cheeky
Thanks and Reputation points : 41
Points : 1892
Registration date : 2007-08-19
Re: Parenting the Supernanny way does not improve behaviour
I suppose it's the way it reads, very critical. Kids will be kids eh, the docs look for clinical reasons to explain behaviour.
''And forcing disobedient toddlers to have "quiet time" to reflect on their bad behaviour – a technique that has been widely adopted by British parents – made no difference to children's behaviour, the study showed.''
How is it forcing? Its a measure that a parent is taking, it makes it sound so awful lol.
''And forcing disobedient toddlers to have "quiet time" to reflect on their bad behaviour – a technique that has been widely adopted by British parents – made no difference to children's behaviour, the study showed.''
How is it forcing? Its a measure that a parent is taking, it makes it sound so awful lol.
Re: Parenting the Supernanny way does not improve behaviour
Did anyone see that programme, Bringing up Baby lol. Claire Verity and her military style parenting?
Re: Parenting the Supernanny way does not improve behaviour
Oh, while I'm here (didn't know where to post this) wondered if anyone on here has the documentary Extraordinary Breastfeeding Feb 06 that I can borrow? I lent mine to someone and never got it back.
I'd like to show my friend. I have found it on utube but it's not the whole programme.
I'd like to show my friend. I have found it on utube but it's not the whole programme.
Re: Parenting the Supernanny way does not improve behaviour
Im sure you can find it on the internet on your tube?
Also the thing about Claire verity, please do not get me started on that silly cow She needs shooting!
Also the thing about Claire verity, please do not get me started on that silly cow She needs shooting!
Re: Parenting the Supernanny way does not improve behaviour
Thanks. You only get to see the first part tho... cannot locate the other parts.
Re: Parenting the Supernanny way does not improve behaviour
Really, well im sure it helps as she gets a lot of visits on her site.
Re: Parenting the Supernanny way does not improve behaviour
I have disliked this woman ever since she infered that breastfeeding a toddler was wrong and encouraged the mothr to stop
beanie- Number of posts : 136
Age : 46
Tell us about yourself : About you:Mummy to a blue eyed Star and a brown eyed Cuddlebug
Your mood today : Content
Thanks and Reputation points : 0
Points : 0
Registration date : 2007-09-05
Re: Parenting the Supernanny way does not improve behaviour
Who was it? I'm joining in their forum BF area, so will hopefully get my ore in lol
Re: Parenting the Supernanny way does not improve behaviour
beanie wrote:I have disliked this woman ever since she infered that breastfeeding a toddler was wrong and encouraged the mothr to stop
Yes I remember that one, she made it out that the child doesn't need it anymore
Breast Buddies Natural Parenting And Breastfeeding Support Forum. Attachment Parenting :: Pregnancy ,Breastfeeding and Parenting Related News :: Pregnancy, Breastfeeding and Parenting Related News
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum